A few days ago, my 4th gen monochrome 20gb iPod refused to synch or be recognized by iTunes. It was making the oft mentioned and characteristic constant faint clicking sound typically called the "infinite click of death." I prefer to call it "One Infinite Click" after
Apple's HQ address. After doing the Apple-recommended "
5 R's" for what seemed like days (I did it in fits and spurts over two days, since it takes a long time for the iPod to be recognized as it's clicking and whirring), I eventually got it to half-resynch, but then fail, and back to the "One Infinite Click."
Macworld is on the 9th, so I figured I should wait to hear what the Steve's going to announce before making the drive all the way to Boulder or Denver to drool at those respective Apple Stores or buying something on line, just in case the prices drop. The next best thing would be getting my hands dirty and trying to figure out what causes this.
After a bit of Googling, there're three main solutions I found on-line for "One Infinite Click," in ascending invasiveness:
- Reformat the iPod hard drive with Windows
- Reseat the HD cables
- Replace the HD with a similar model Toshiba MK2006GAL 20gb drive
The iPod was already behaving badly, taking a long time for any of my computers to recognize it, so the first step to reformat the HD was to put it into
disk mode. After a long time (over 10 minutes or so) Windows decided to recognize it and the iPod itself stopped clicking long enough to be recognized, I used the disk utility to reformat H:\ (quick, NTFS). Disconnected, reconnected and iTunes 7 fired up and wanted to restore the software on the iPod. Great so far. Disconnected and connected to an external power source, as requested, let it do its thing then reconnected to the machine. ITunes 7 wanted to restore again. Ok. One more cycle of that business and it's clear that reformatting isn't the solution. I've got to open the thing up.
Pricewatch's and Froogle's listings for the MK2006GAL are around $100, so I figure I'd better do step 2 before spending the money. Opening it up was easier than I thought: jeweler's screwdrivers and a bit of plastic stressing until I figured out which way to wedge and it popped open. The internals look like all
the pictures on the net. I pushed the IDE HD connector on the HD. I think it felt a bit loose, but I don't know. Reseating complete.
I went through The Process: attached the iPod to the machine, let it restore, disconnected and attached to a power source, and back to the computer. I think I may have heard one click as iTunes started to copy over the 3000 mp3 items, but I can't really tell.
Lucky me, the whole library loaded and it seems to work great! No need to spend the $100 or so for a new hard drive (yet). I may, though, spend the $30 for a newer battery, as the one I have has been dying for a while.
The Steve announced the iPhone and iTV, but no change in prices to the 30 and 80gb iPods. I'm very happy with my 20gb 4th gen, especially now that it works!